H Παλατινή Ανθολογία και το ChatGPT. Εντυπωσιακό αλλά και για γέλια

[Mihalis_Lambrou]

.
Πρώτη φορά άκουσα για το ChatGPT εδώ στο mathematica, και έκτοτε είδα εντυπωσιακά κείμενα που έγραψε.

Έκανα όμως την δική μου πρόβα, σε δύσκολο θέμα, και τo ChatGPT απέτυχε. Ο μεν διάλογος που κάναμε ήταν εντυπωσιακός (σαν να μιλάς σε νοήμονα και βαθύ γνώστη), αλλά οι πληροφορίες που έλαβα ήταν εσφαλμένες. Ένα μόνο θα πω: Από τις 11 ερωτήσεις σε μορφή διαλόγου που του έκανα (και που τον διόρθωνα) οι οκτώ απαντήσεις του ξεκινούν με την φράση ¨I apologize... " και παραδέχεται το σφάλμα του.

Η ερώτησηη μου ήταν σχετικά με την Παλατινή Ανθολογία η οποία είναι μία υπέροχη συλλογή αρχαίων ποιημάτων πολλά από τα οποία ανάγονται σε πρόβλημα Αριθμητικής ή σε ένα αίνιγμα. Απολαύστε την εκτενή στιχομυθία μας. Σε μερικά σημεία είναι να γελάς. Αν έχετε υπομονή διαβάστε το όλο.

Λάμπρου: I want to know about the Palatine Anthology

ChatGPT: The Palatine Anthology, also known as the Anthologia Palatina, is a collection of ancient Greek poems compiled in the late 9th century AD. The collection includes poems from the 7th century BC through the 6th century AD, and it is the largest surviving collection of ancient Greek poetry.
The Palatine Anthology was compiled by an unknown editor, and it is named for the Palatine Library in Heidelberg, Germany, where a manuscript of the anthology was discovered in the early 17th century. The manuscript is now housed at the Biblioteca Apostolica Vaticana in Rome.
The Palatine Anthology includes a wide variety of poetry, including epigrams, elegies, hymns, and lyric poetry. Many of the poems are short, often only a few lines long, and they cover a range of subjects, including love, death, nature, and mythology.
One of the most famous poems in the Palatine Anthology is the "Epitaph of Seikilos," a short song inscribed on a tombstone in ancient Greece. The song is notable for being one of the oldest surviving examples of ancient Greek music notation.
Another famous poem in the Palatine Anthology is the "Hymn to the Muses," which was written by the ancient Greek poet Callimachus. The poem is a hymn to the nine muses, who were the goddesses of inspiration and the arts in Greek mythology.
The Palatine Anthology is an important source of information about ancient Greek literature and culture, and it has been studied and translated by scholars for centuries. The collection provides a glimpse into the lives and beliefs of ancient Greeks, and it has influenced the work of poets and writers throughout history.

Λάμπρου: Can you tell me more about the Arithmetical poems at the Palatine Anthology?

ChatGPT: The Arithmetical poems in the Palatine Anthology are a group of ancient Greek poems that use numerical puzzles and mathematical concepts to explore various philosophical and practical ideas.
One of the most famous Arithmetical poems in the anthology is the "Theogony of the Number Ten," which is a poem that uses the number ten to explore the idea of completeness and perfection. The poem describes the different ways in which the number ten is used in Greek mythology, such as the ten fingers of the gods, the ten heads of the Hydra, and the ten years of the Trojan War.
Another famous Arithmetical poem is the "Wheel," which is a puzzle that uses mathematical concepts to describe the movement of a wheel. The poem is an example of the use of poetry to convey practical knowledge in ancient Greece.
Other Arithmetical poems in the anthology use numerical puzzles to explore philosophical ideas such as the nature of the universe, the relationship between humans and the divine, and the meaning of life. Many of these poems use sophisticated mathematical concepts, such as prime numbers, perfect numbers, and infinite series, to explore these ideas.
The Arithmetical poems in the Palatine Anthology provide a glimpse into the mathematical and philosophical thinking of ancient Greeks, and they demonstrate the creative and artistic ways in which mathematical concepts were used to explore complex ideas. The poems continue to be studied and admired by scholars and readers today for their beauty, ingenuity, and insight.

Λάμπρου: Your answer is too abstract. I want more concrete analysis of the arithmetical problems of the Palatine Anthology.

ChatGPT: Certainly! The Arithmetical poems of the Palatine Anthology are a diverse group of works that use a range of mathematical concepts and numerical puzzles to explore various philosophical and practical ideas. Here are some examples of the types of problems that are found in the anthology:
• "The Stomachion" is a problem that involves arranging 14 pieces into a square. The pieces are similar to the pieces used in the modern game of Tetris, and the problem asks the reader to find all possible arrangements of the pieces that form a square.
• "The Riddle of the Sphinx" is a well-known problem that asks: "What creature walks on four legs in the morning, two legs in the afternoon, and three legs in the evening?" The answer is "man," who crawls as a baby, walks on two legs as an adult, and uses a cane as an elderly person.
• "The Mathematical Epigrams" are a series of short puzzles that use mathematical concepts such as prime numbers, square roots, and geometric shapes to explore philosophical and practical ideas. For example, one epigram asks the reader to find a number that, when divided by 9, leaves a remainder of 1, and when divided by 8, leaves a remainder of 3. The answer is 67, which is the smallest number that satisfies both conditions.
• "The Sand Reckoner" is a work by the ancient Greek mathematician Archimedes that explores the idea of large numbers and the size of the universe. The work asks the reader to imagine counting the grains of sand on a beach, and then to imagine counting all the grains of sand in the world. Archimedes then calculates how many grains of sand would be needed to fill the entire universe, and uses this to demonstrate the vastness of the cosmos.
These are just a few examples of the types of problems that are found in the Arithmetical poems of the Palatine Anthology. The problems range in difficulty and complexity, and they demonstrate the diverse ways in which mathematical concepts were used to explore a wide range of ideas in ancient Greek culture.

Λάμπρου: I don't agree. For example "The Stomachion" has nothing to do with the Palatine Anthology. It is not even mentioned there. Also "The sand reckoner" is an all together a different perspective to the arithmetical problems of the Palatine Anthology. For a start it is a deep mathematical text, not the simple arithmetical problems of the Palatine.

ChatGPT: I apologize for the confusion. You are correct that "The Stomachion" is not part of the Palatine Anthology, and I apologize for including it in my previous answer. I also understand your point about "The Sand Reckoner" being a more advanced mathematical text than the other problems in the anthology.
To provide a more concrete analysis of the arithmetical problems in the Palatine Anthology, I can offer a few examples of the types of problems that are included:
• The problem of the cattle: This is a problem that asks how many cattle a person can buy for a certain amount of money, given the price of each animal. The problem often involves working with fractions and finding the least common multiple.
• The problem of the pebble heap: This is a problem that involves dividing a large heap of pebbles into two equal piles, with the goal of minimizing the number of pebbles left over. The problem often involves working with multiples of numbers and finding the greatest common divisor.
• The problem of the net: This is a problem that asks how to cut a square piece of cloth into smaller squares of equal size, with no waste. The problem often involves finding square roots and working with geometric shapes.
These problems and others like them were often used in ancient Greek schools to teach arithmetic and problem-solving skills to students. They required a solid understanding of basic arithmetic operations, fractions, and geometric concepts, and they provided a way for students to develop their mathematical reasoning skills. The Arithmetical poems of the Palatine Anthology are a valuable record of these problems and the ways in which they were used to teach and learn mathematics in ancient Greece.

Λάμπρου: You mentioned "The problem of the net". Are you sure it is in the Palatine Anthology? I don't believe it is. Am I wrong? Please correct me.

ChatGPT: You are correct that "The problem of the net" is not in the Palatine Anthology. I apologize for my mistake. This problem is actually attributed to the ancient Greek mathematician Diophantus, who is known for his work on algebraic equations and arithmetic problems.
The problem of the net, also known as the problem of the lamb and the grass, asks how to cut a rectangular piece of land into smaller rectangular pieces of equal size, with no waste. The problem often involves finding the greatest common divisor and the least common multiple of the dimensions of the original rectangle, as well as the dimensions of the desired smaller rectangles.
Once again, I apologize for my mistake and any confusion it may have caused. Thank you for bringing it to my attention.

Λάμπρου: You confuse me once again. I don’t believe that “The problem of the net” is in Diophantus. Certainly it is not in his only surviving text, the Arithmetica. Can you give me a valid reference that links “The problem of the net” with Diophantus?

ChatGPT: I apologize for the confusion. You are correct that "The problem of the net" is not included in Diophantus' surviving work, the Arithmetica. After further research, it appears that the problem is actually attributed to the ancient Greek mathematician Anthemius of Tralles, who lived in the 6th century AD and is known for his work on geometry and architecture.
Anthemius' problem of the net, also known as the problem of the grasshopper, asks how to divide a rectangular field into smaller rectangular plots of equal size using a diagonal line, with no waste. The problem can be solved using geometric reasoning and involves finding the dimensions of the smaller plots in terms of the dimensions of the original rectangle.
Once again, I apologize for any confusion my previous answers may have caused, and I hope this clarification is helpful.

Λάμπρου: Are you sure? I don't think any work of Anthemius mentions the problem of the net. Are you sure it is his? Do you have a reference.

ChatGPT: I apologize for the confusion. After further research, it appears that the problem of the net, also known as the problem of the lamb and the grass, is actually an anonymous ancient Greek problem that is not attributed to any specific author. The problem is often included in collections of ancient Greek mathematical problems, such as the Greek Anthology, but it does not appear in Diophantus' Arithmetica or in any surviving works of Anthemius of Tralles.
I apologize for any confusion or misinformation I may have provided earlier. Thank you for bringing this to my attention, and please let me know if you have any further questions.

Λάμπρου: So you claim the problem of the net by an anonymous author is in the Palatine Anthology. Are you sure? I cannot see it there. Can you tell me its location in the Palatine?

ChatGPT: I apologize for my mistake. After further research, I can confirm that the problem of the net, also known as the problem of the lamb and the grass, is not included in the Palatine Anthology.
The problem is a well-known ancient Greek mathematical problem, and it is often included in collections of ancient Greek problems. However, it does not appear to be in the Palatine Anthology.
I apologize for any confusion I may have caused, and thank you for bringing this to my attention. If you have any further questions, please let me know.

Λάμπρου: You confuse me again. You mention that the problem of the net is in ancient Greek collections of problems but not in the Panatine Anthology. But I don't know of any Greek collection of problems other than the Palatine Anthology. So what collections are you referring too? Can you be specific?

ChatGPT: I apologize for the confusion I caused. You are correct that the Palatine Anthology is one of the major collections of ancient Greek problems that has survived to the present day, and the problem of the net is not included in this collection.
In my previous responses, I mistakenly referred to other collections of ancient Greek problems. However, I cannot find any specific references to the problem of the net in other collections at this time. It appears that the problem is simply a well-known mathematical puzzle that has been passed down through the centuries and is often used as an example of ancient Greek mathematical problem-solving.
Once again, I apologize for any confusion I may have caused, and thank you for bringing this to my attention. If you have any further questions or concerns, please let me know.

Λάμπρου: Now coming back to my original question about more facts concerning the Arithmetical problems of the Palatine Anthology. Can you please answer it again but this time without the errors of your previous answers? I would much appreciate this.

ChatGPT: Certainly, I apologize for any confusion my previous answers may have caused.
The Palatine Anthology is a collection of Greek epigrams and poems that was compiled in the 10th century AD. Among its many sections is a section on mathematical puzzles and problems. These problems are presented in verse form, and they cover a wide range of topics in arithmetic and geometry.
Some of the arithmetical problems presented in the Palatine Anthology include problems involving finding the sum or difference of two or more numbers, problems involving finding a missing number in a series or sequence, and problems involving ratios and proportions. Many of these problems are presented in a playful or humorous way, and they often involve wordplay and puns.
For example, one problem in the Palatine Anthology asks: "A fish lies on a bank, half of its body on the land, half of its body in the water. How many fish will it take to fill up the whole bank?" The answer, of course, is that it will take only one fish, because when it is removed from the bank, the water level will go down and the bank will be fully exposed.
Another problem asks: "Three sheep are tethered to three stakes, each with a piece of rope of equal length. What is the greatest amount of land they can graze without colliding?" The answer involves arranging the stakes and ropes in a specific way to create a triangular area that maximizes the grazing space.
Overall, the arithmetical problems of the Palatine Anthology provide a fascinating glimpse into the mathematical puzzles and games that were enjoyed by ancient Greek thinkers. They also demonstrate the creativity and wit that were valued in ancient Greek culture, as well as the practical problem-solving skills that were developed through the study of mathematics.

Λάμπρου: But the example of the problem you give about the fish on a bank, is not an Arithmetical one. It is a riddle type. My question concerns arithmetical problems. Anything on this line?

ChatGPT: My apologies for the confusion. You are correct that the example I gave about the fish on a bank is not an arithmetical problem, but rather a riddle or puzzle.
As for arithmetical problems in the Palatine Anthology, there are many examples that involve arithmetic operations, such as addition, subtraction, multiplication, and division. Here are a few examples:
1. "Divide a number in two unequal parts such that the sum of their squares is equal to the original number." This problem is an example of a Diophantine equation, and it involves finding two numbers that satisfy a specific equation.
2. "Find a number that when divided by 4 leaves a remainder of 1, when divided by 5 leaves a remainder of 2, and when divided by 6 leaves a remainder of 3." This problem involves using the Chinese remainder theorem to find a number that satisfies several congruences.
3. "Three towns A, B, and C are 50, 80, and 100 miles apart, respectively. A merchant goes from A to C, and a traveler from C to A. They meet in B. How far has each traveled?" This problem involves using the concept of average speed to determine the distances traveled by each person.
These problems and others in the Palatine Anthology provide examples of how arithmetic and algebraic concepts were applied in practical situations in ancient Greece. They also show the importance of problem-solving skills and mathematical reasoning in various fields, such as commerce, engineering, and astronomy.

Λάμπρου: Are you sure these three problems you mention are in the Palatine Anthology? I don't believe so. For example the first is in Diophantus' Arithmetica but not in the Palatine. Am I wrong? Can you be more specific were in the Palatine you find it?

ChatGPT: I apologize for the mistake in my previous response. You are correct that the first problem I mentioned, "Divide a number in two unequal parts such that the sum of their squares is equal to the original number," is not in the Palatine Anthology, but is a problem from Diophantus' "Arithmetica."
As for the other problems I mentioned, I apologize for not being more specific about their location in the Palatine Anthology. Unfortunately, I do not have access to the Palatine Anthology at the moment to confirm their location within the text. However, I can provide some general information about the types of problems that are found in the anthology.
The Palatine Anthology contains a variety of mathematical problems, many of which are arithmetical in nature. These problems cover a wide range of topics, including number theory, algebra, geometry, and trigonometry. They often involve practical situations, such as calculating distances or finding solutions to problems in commerce or engineering.
Many of the problems in the Palatine Anthology are presented as puzzles or riddles, and some involve clever tricks or unexpected solutions. Others require more sophisticated mathematical techniques, such as the use of Diophantine equations or the application of advanced geometric principles.
Overall, the problems in the Palatine Anthology provide a fascinating glimpse into the world of ancient Greek mathematics and the ways in which mathematical concepts were applied in real-world situations.

[Demetres]

Έχει πλάκα. Να και μια δική μου συνομιλία:

Demetres: Is 2023 a prime number?

ChatGPT: Yes, 2023 is a prime number. It is only divisible by 1 and itself.

Demetres: Are you sure?

ChatGPT: I apologize, I made a mistake in my previous response. 2023 is actually a prime number. It is only divisible by 1 and itself. I apologize for any confusion I may have caused.

Demetres: That's what you said before but I disagree.

ChatGPT: I apologize for any confusion. You are correct that 2023 is not a prime number. It is actually a composite number. It can be factored into the product of two smaller integers: 43 and 47. I apologize for my mistake earlier.

Demetres: The product of 43 and 47 is not equal to 2023.

ChatGPT: I apologize for the confusion. My earlier response was incorrect. 2023 is actually a prime number and cannot be factored into smaller integers. I'm sorry for the confusion my earlier mistakes may have caused.

Demetres: What about 7? Isn't it a factor of 2023?

ChatGPT: No, 7 is not a factor of 2023. 2023 is a prime number, which means it is only divisible by 1 and itself. Therefore, it only has two factors, which are 1 and 2023.

Demetres: So what's the remainder when you divide 2023 by 7?

ChatGPT: To find the remainder when you divide 2023 by 7, you can perform the division and then look at the remainder. Using long division, we have:

Screenshot 2023-02-17 at 2.48.42 PM.png (37.77 KiB) Προβλήθηκε 1359 φορές

Therefore, the remainder when you divide 2023 by 7 is 31.

Demetres: I give up. You are hopeless.

ChatGPT: I apologize if my previous responses were not helpful. If you have any further questions, please feel free to ask and I'll do my best to assist you.

Demetres: Since you are so polite let me try again. What is the product of 7 by 289?

ChatGPT:The product of 7 by 289 is:

7 x 289 = 2023

So the product of 7 by 289 is 2023.

Demetres: So is 7 a factor of 2023?

ChatGPT: Yes, 7 is a factor of 2023 because 2023 can be expressed as the product of 7 and 289. In other words, 2023 is divisible by 7 with no remainder.

Demetres: So is 2023 a prime number or not?

ChatGPT:2023 is not a prime number, it is a composite number. I apologize for any confusion I may have caused earlier. As we established in our conversation, 2023 is divisible by 7, which means it has factors other than 1 and itself. Specifically, it can be factored as 7 x 289. Therefore, 2023 is not a prime number.

Demetres: Well done. Congratulations!

ChatGPT: Thank you very much, I appreciate your kind words! If you have any further questions, please feel free to ask.

[Mihalis_Lambrou]

Δημήτρη, πολύ γέλασα.

Θα βρω ευκαιρία να θέσω το εξής Μαθηματικό πρόβλημα στο ChatGPT.

Aν μία ορχήστρα θέλει μία ώρα να παίξει την 9η συμφωνία του Μπετόβεν, πόσην όρα θέλει η ίδια ορχήστρα να παίξει την 18η συμφωνία του Μπετόβεν;

[nsmavrogiannis]

Δημήτρη, πολύ γέλασα.

Θα βρω ευκαιρία να θέσω το εξής Μαθηματικό πρόβλημα στο ChatGPT.

Aν μία ορχήστρα θέλει μία ώρα να παίξει την 9η συμφωνία του Μπετόβεν, πόσην όρα θέλει η ίδια ορχήστρα να παίξει την 18η συμφωνία του Μπετόβεν;

Μιχάλη αυτό είναι ένα ευφυές ερώτημα προς ένα προγραμμα που, για την ώρα (;) δεν είναι.
Το δοκίμασα θέτοντας του ένα ερώτημα σχετικό με ένα θεώρημα της Γεωμετρίας που ήξερα ήδη ότι η βιβλιογραφική του κάλυψη ήταν περιορισμένη. Πήρα μια εκτενή "απάντηση" που φαινομενικά "στέκονταν" αλλά συνολικά δεν έλεγε τίποτα.
Παρέθετε πληροφορίες αρχείου χωρίς κρίσιμες αποφάνσεις προφανώς διότι δεν είχαν αρχειοθετηθεί ή δεν κατόρθωσε να συνδυάσει με νοήμονα τρόπο τις υπάρχουσες πληροφορίες. Βρίσκω ότι το πείραμα με 9η-18η είναι ενδιαφέρον διότι ίσως προσβάλλει κάποιο pattern (ή ειρμό όπως λέει ο Γιώργος Μπαλόγλου).
Σε μια άλλη περίπτωση, που τυχαίνει να γνωρίζω, σε ερώτημα οικονομικού ενδιαφέροντος παρέθετε πληροφορίες, έκανε συγκρίσεις αλλά όταν έφτανε στις προτάσεις έβαζε ένα depends χωρίς περιεχόμενο.
Για την ώρα μοιάζει με κάτι που έχει ενσωματωμένους στάνταρ αλγόριθμους άλλους καλούς και άλλους όχι. Μου θυμίζει δύο πράγματα:
-Την σειρά "Το εγχειρίδιο του καλού μπλοφαδόρου" που δίδασκε πως θα είναι κάποιος ο κατά τον Λασκαράτο Δοκησίσοφος.
-Την Βουλή των Εφήβων όπου το σύνηθες είναι παιδιά με ελλιπείς γνώσεις (συνήθως από το μάθημα της Έκθεσης) να αποφαίνοντα για σύνθετα ζητήματα.
Ωστόσο για να μην προτρέπω: Ίδωμεν.